Tags

  • Published on

    FINER and PICO

    Comparator FINER Hypothesis Testing Intervention Outcome PICO Population Post-positivism Research Design Research Question Sampling Method Statistical Power Analysis Statistics

    An amalgamation of philosophy and objectivity

    The research question is the foundation of everything empirical

    Research questions (and answering them) are always the primary focus of anything and everything empirical, methodological, epidemiological, and statistical. Without a research question, there is no reason to conduct a study or run statistics.

    The following are DIRECTLY derived from research questions:

    1. Null and alternative hypotheses (hypothesis testing and inferential statistics)
    2. Research design (observation or experimental)
    3. Population of interest (inclusion and exclusion criteria) 
    4. Sampling method (non-probability or probability)
    5. Intervention or independent variable (categorical, ordinal, or continuous)
    6. Confounding or control variables (secondary, tertiary, and ancillary research questions)
    7. Comparator or control treatment (categorical, ordinal, or continuous)
    8. Outcome or dependent variable (categorical, ordinal, or continuous)
    9. Outcome and design for an a priori power analysis to calculate sample size
    10. Structure of the database (between-subjects, within-subjects, or multivariate) and code book
    11. Statistical tests used (descriptive, between-subjects, within-subjects, correlations, survival, or multivariate)

    Researchers must take the appropriate amount of time to fully formulate and refine research questions. SO MUCH is dependent upon it for their study. Luckily, this task is made easier with the use of two prevalent mnemonics: FINER (feasible, interesting, novel, ethical, relevant) and PICO (population, intervention, comparator, outcome).

    FINER is a more of a philosophy for writing research questions. The arguments for the "F," "I," "N," "E," and "R" are all and informed upon by the empirical literature in the area of empirical or clinical interest. Researchers especially have to be well vested in the most current literature in order to make sound arguments for interesting, novel, and relevant questions.

    PICO is employed to explicitly and operationally define the population of interest, the intervention, the comparator, and the outcome in a research question. It is also more readily applicable in busy clinical and empirical environments and when writing literature search queries.  

    These two mnemonics compliment each other very well in applied empirical and clinical environments. The post-positivist philosophy of social and medical sciences lends itself well to FINER. Measurement of observable constructs and the application of experimental designs through the PICO mnemonic is also strongly reflective of a post-positivist philosophical orientation. Together, the "why" and "what" questions associated with conducting research can be argued in an evidence-based, objective, and logically sound fashion.
  • Published on

    The research question is the foundation of everything empirical

    FINER PICO Research Question

    Foundation for measurement, design, power, and statistics

    80% of preliminary study planning should be given to the research question

    As a biostatistical consultant at an academic regional medical campus, I am supposed to spend 80% of my time working with residents, fellows, faculty, clinicians, researchers, nurses, pharmacists, and hospital staff to formulate and refine their research question. THAT is how important it is to any research study. 

    A research question is cultivated through researchers' efforts to know the existing literature, their clinical expertise and interests, their collaboration with peers, and their intrinsic motivation towards scientific discovery and innovation. Answerable, appropriate, meaningful, and purposeful research questions make valid and needed contributions to the literature.

    Deductive reasoning should be used when formulating a research question. Oftentimes, researchers will want to answer EVERY possible question and collect data on EVERY single variable that they can in hopes of finding SOMETHING SIGNIFICANT. This is not the way that REAL science works. A focused and refined research question is the basis for constructing and executing research. This does not mean that researchers cannot ask secondary, tertiary, and ancillary research questions as demographic, clinical, and confounding variables are yielded from literature reviews! Of course, these are important questions to ask and often lead to great discoveries! (Example:  Viagra) However, having ONE research question that serves as the foundation for a study is extremely important and should not be overlooked!

    Many novice researchers will plan an entire study around a type of research design or a statistic that they read in an article. REMEMBER, research designs and statistical tests are chosen to answer researcher questions, NOT the inverse.

    All of this being said, there are two existing frameworks that greatly assist in formulating (FINER) and refining (PICO) research questions. FINER stands for feasible, interesting, novel, interesting, and relevant. PICO stands for population, intervention, comparator, and outcome.